Review sản phẩm
Thẻ thông minh nào thông minh hơn?
Th3
Thẻ thông minh nào thông minh hơn?
Sự bùng nổ của công nghệ Internet vạn vật (IoT) đã dẫn đến sự xuất hiện ngày càng nhiều các loại thẻ thông minh, phục vụ đa dạng nhu cầu từ quản lý kho hàng, theo dõi tài sản đến tự động hóa nhà cửa. Tuy nhiên, việc lựa chọn loại thẻ phù hợp có thể khá khó khăn, đặc biệt khi thị trường tràn ngập các sản phẩm với tính năng và giá cả khác nhau. Bài viết này sẽ phân tích các yếu tố quan trọng cần xem xét để giúp bạn đưa ra quyết định sáng suốt khi chọn mua thẻ thông minh.
- Công nghệ kết nối: Đây là yếu tố quyết định phạm vi hoạt động và khả năng tương thích của thẻ. Các công nghệ phổ biến bao gồm:
- NFC (Near Field Communication): Phạm vi hoạt động ngắn, thường dưới 10cm, phù hợp cho các ứng dụng yêu cầu độ bảo mật cao và tương tác gần như ví dụ như thanh toán không tiếp xúc, mở khóa cửa.
- Bluetooth Low Energy (BLE): Phạm vi hoạt động rộng hơn NFC, tiết kiệm năng lượng, lý tưởng cho việc theo dõi tài sản, định vị trong nhà, và tích hợp vào các hệ thống nhà thông minh.
- RFID (Radio-Frequency Identification): Phạm vi hoạt động rất rộng, có thể lên đến vài mét, thường được sử dụng trong quản lý kho hàng, theo dõi hàng hóa trong chuỗi cung ứng. Tuy nhiên, RFID thường có mức độ bảo mật thấp hơn so với NFC và BLE.
- LoRaWAN: Công nghệ mạng diện rộng tầm xa, lý tưởng cho các ứng dụng theo dõi tài sản ngoài trời, quản lý nông nghiệp thông minh, với ưu điểm về phạm vi phủ sóng và tiết kiệm năng lượng.
- Các tính năng: Thẻ thông minh không chỉ đơn thuần là một thiết bị nhận dạng. Nhiều thẻ hiện nay được tích hợp thêm các tính năng như:
- Khả năng đo lường: Một số thẻ có thể đo nhiệt độ, độ ẩm, ánh sáng, gia tốc… Điều này giúp mở rộng khả năng ứng dụng trong lĩnh vực giám sát môi trường, quản lý sức khỏe.
- Bộ nhớ: Dung lượng bộ nhớ ảnh hưởng đến khả năng lưu trữ dữ liệu của thẻ, quan trọng trong các ứng dụng yêu cầu ghi lại nhiều thông tin.
- Pin: Tuổi thọ pin là yếu tố cần xem xét, đặc biệt đối với các thẻ hoạt động độc lập không cần kết nối nguồn điện liên tục.
- Bảo mật: Mức độ bảo mật của thẻ cần được ưu tiên, đặc biệt đối với các ứng dụng liên quan đến tài chính hoặc thông tin nhạy cảm. Các phương pháp mã hóa và xác thực cần được xem xét kỹ lưỡng.
- Khả năng tương thích: Trước khi mua, hãy đảm bảo thẻ thông minh tương thích với hệ thống hiện có hoặc dự kiến sử dụng. Điều này bao gồm cả phần cứng và phần mềm. Kiểm tra kỹ các thông số kỹ thuật và hỗ trợ từ nhà sản xuất.
-
Giá cả: Giá cả của thẻ thông minh rất đa dạng, phụ thuộc vào công nghệ, tính năng và nhà sản xuất. Hãy cân nhắc kỹ lưỡng giữa chi phí và lợi ích mà thẻ mang lại.
Kết luận: Việc lựa chọn thẻ thông minh phụ thuộc nhiều vào nhu cầu cụ thể của người dùng. Hãy đánh giá kỹ các yếu tố như công nghệ kết nối, tính năng, khả năng tương thích và giá cả để tìm ra sản phẩm phù hợp nhất. Không có một loại thẻ thông minh nào là “thông minh nhất” mà chỉ có loại thẻ phù hợp nhất với từng ứng dụng.
#thẻthôngminh #IoT #NFC #BLE #RFID #LoRaWAN #nhàthôngminh #quảnlýkhohàng #theotõitàisản #côngnghệ #smarthome #automation
-
Your changes have been saved
The practical pick
Tile Pro (2024)
$28 $35 Save $7
The Tile Pro stands out with its long Bluetooth range, loud built-in alarm, and access to Tile’s extensive community network. However, the Tile Pro doesn’t support newer smartphone tracking networks like Google’s Find My Device or Apple’s Find My, and some of its best features are locked behind subscription plans.
Pros
- Strong, reliable tracking network
- Excellent Bluetooth range
- Loud alarm
Cons
- Needs battery replacements
- Doesn’t support any Find My networks
-
Your changes have been saved
Lots of potential
Pebblebee Tag Universal
The Pebblebee Universal Tag shows promise. Its compact size and ability to stick almost anywhere can be handy around the house. Indoors, it can help locate misplaced essentials, but Pebblebee’s current reliance on an underdeveloped Google network keeps it from serving as a reliable outdoor tracker.
Pros
- Compact form factor
- Rechargeable battery
- Cross-platform compatibility
Cons
- Doesn’t work on Pebblebee’s own network
- Doesn’t offer reliable tracking as of now
It’s a jungle out there, and it’s easy to lose your belongings in the hustle and bustle. Thankfully, we have convenient item trackers to help us keep tabs on our valuables. While Apple fans have long enjoyed AirTags and Apple’s massive Find My network, Android owners were often stuck with smaller-scale options. Tile managed to make the best of this situation, building a trusted brand and reliable products over time. Its latest lineup for 2024, highlighted by the updated Tile Pro, shows the company refining what it does best.
But, Google’s Find My Device network finally arrived this year, promising to be backed by nearly every Android phone out there. That’s where the Pebblebee Tag Universal comes in — one of the first trackers to leverage Google’s wide-reaching network. The big question now is whether this fresh face can stand up to the familiar favorite. In this guide, we’ll compare the Tile Pro (2024) with the Pebblebee Tag Universal, helping you decide which one might be the right fit for your routine.
Price, availability, and specs
Evenly matched
The Tile Pro (2024) has the highest price tag in Tile’s current lineup, landing at $35 for a single tracker. However, you can snag a better deal by purchasing it in packs. A two-pack costs $60, and if you opt for a four-pack in black, you’ll pay just $80 total — which averages out to a more wallet-friendly $20 per unit. A white four-pack is technically more expensive at $140, but it commonly goes on sale for under $100.
On top of the upfront cost, you should also consider Tile’s potential subscription fees and Life360 services, which we will get to in a bit. If you want to get your hands on a Tile Pro, you’ll find it widely available through the official Tile website, Amazon, Best Buy, Walmart, and other major retailers.
Pebblebee’s new Universal trackers — Tag, Clip, and Card — are priced at $35 and designed to work with Android and iOS. If you’re looking to buy in bulk, you can decrease the price per unit to $33 with a two-pack ($65) or go even lower with a four-pack for $120, cutting the cost to $30 each. You’ll find these universal options on Pebblebee’s website, as well as Amazon and Best Buy.
Although Pebblebee initially introduced versions specifically for Android earlier this year, the company has since wiped them off its website, leaving buyers with a straightforward, cross-platform choice instead.
-
Tile Pro (2024)
- Material
- Plastic
- Connectivity
- Bluetooth
- Battery
- 3 years (replaceable CR2032)
- Range
- Up to 500 ft (152 m)
- Water Resistance
- IP68
- Dimensions
- 34mm x 52.1mm x 7.5mm
- Weight
- 12 grams
-
Pebblebee Tag Universal
- Material
- Plastic
- Connectivity
- Bluetooth
- Battery
- Rechargeable; up to 8 months per charge
- Range
- Up to 300ft
- Water Resistance
- IPX6
- Dimensions
- 26 × 40 × 4.5mm
- Weight
- 6.5g
Read our review
Review: The Tile Pro is still the only worthwhile tracker for most Android users
Farther range, longer battery life, louder siren
Read our review
Review: Pebblebee’s new Universal trackers still aren’t right for Android users
Pebblebee has given up on its network
Build and design
Built differently
The Tile Pro is shaped like a sturdy key fob, complete with an integrated loop, so it can hang from your keys or attach to anything with a carabiner. It comes in black and white, measuring about 34mm x 52.1mm, with a thickness of around 7.5mm. It weighs in at about 12g and houses a standard battery that lasts around a year before needing a replacement.
The Pebblebee Tag Universal, on the other hand, is slim and rectangular, about the size of a slightly elongated SD card, but roughly twice as thick. It’s only available in black and weighs around 6.5g. It is smaller and lighter than the Tile Pro, measuring 26mm x 40mm x 4.5mm.
Its compact size and included adhesive strip make it incredibly versatile; it can stick to almost anything, from your phone case to your wallet. Additionally, it comes with a silicone sleeve designed to slip onto a bag strap. Meanwhile, the Tile Pro’s built-in loop design means it’s easiest to use as a traditional key chain tracker. If you’re eyeing a Pebblebee product for a key chain-like use case, you might want to check out the Pebblebee Clip.
The Pebblebee Tag Universal boasts an IPX6 rating, meaning it can handle splashes and rain, but submerging it is a no-go. The Tile Pro, on the other hand, is a true survivor with an IP68 rating. This rugged tracker can withstand dust and submersion in up to 5ft of water, making it a more durable choice for outdoor adventures or pets who love water.
One area where the Pebblebee Tag Universal shines is its rechargeable battery. It comes with a magnetic charging puck that connects to any USB Type-C charger, and Pebblebee claims it can last up to eight months on a single charge. While rechargeable batteries tend to lose capacity over time. Even if their lifespan decreases, charging every few months is arguably more convenient than replacing disposable batteries annually, which is the case with the Tile Pro.
Features and tracking
Almost one-sided
When it comes to everyday use, both the Tile Pro and Pebblebee Tag Universal stick to the same fundamental formula: they’re Bluetooth trackers you attach to something you don’t want to lose. Within range, you can trigger an alarm to help locate your item. And in the case of the Tile Pro, pressing the button on the tracker can even make your phone ring — handy when you’re scrambling for your misplaced device.
The Tile Pro (2024) raises the bar on Bluetooth distance, claiming a solid 500ft range in perfect conditions. That’s a big number, even if it’s hard to match in the real world thanks to walls and other interference. Pebblebee’s Tag aims for up to 300ft, which is nothing to sneeze at, but still falls short of Tile’s longer reach.
Beyond Bluetooth range, the Tile Pro relies on Tile’s vast network of over 50 million devices. When a Tile tracker is outside Bluetooth range, any device in the Tile network that comes within range of the tracker can anonymously update its location. This means that even if your own phone is far away, you can still get location updates on your lost item.
During our testing, the Tile Pro consistently pinged its location every 5 to 10 minutes, even in less populated areas. Tile’s network is further strengthened by its integration with Life360, a family safety app. This means that Bluetooth-enabled phones using Life360 can also contribute to the Tile network, significantly expanding its reach. Adding to its safety features, the Tile Pro can be programmed to send an SOS alert to your designated contacts and even law enforcement in case of an emergency. This is a valuable addition for those concerned about personal safety.
The Pebblebee Tag Universal, on the other hand, relies on either Google’s Find My Device network or Apple’s Find My network once it’s outside Bluetooth range. While this sounds promising, Google’s Find My Device network, in its current state, has significant limitations. It requires multiple Android phones to connect with the tracker before updating its location, and even then, the location accuracy can be quite broad, sometimes spanning a 120m radius.
Furthermore, location updates can be infrequent, sometimes occurring only every few hours. This inconsistency can be a major drawback if you need to track something quickly. The Apple side of Pebblebee’s compatibility might fare better, but on Android, it’s a waiting game for the Find My Device network to catch up.
Things to remember
Missing features and network considerations
Neither the Tile Pro nor the Pebblebee Tag Universal offers the razor-sharp precision of Ultra-Wideband (UWB) tracking you’ll find with Apple’s AirTag or Samsung’s Galaxy SmartTag 2. Without UWB’s pinpoint accuracy, both trackers rely on Bluetooth and networks of participating devices to estimate locations. This means you won’t get step-by-step directions to a hidden backpack or purse. Instead, you’re often narrowing down a broad area, and then following the sound of a chime.
While Tile’s network is large enough to serve most needs, its best extra features — like stolen-item reimbursement, detailed location history, and smart alerts when you forget an item — live behind subscription paywalls. Those who don’t mind a simpler experience can skip the subscription and just rely on the basics.
Pebblebee removed some advanced features by dropping its own network support from the Universal models. Instead, you’re banking on Google or Apple to provide a steady stream of location data, which isn’t always ideal in the current state of Android’s Find My Device network.
In short, both trackers do a decent job of guiding you back to your stuff, but they’re not quite as cutting-edge as first-party options from Apple or Samsung. For now, Tile’s established network and booming alarm are its strong suits. At the same time, Pebblebee’s approach hinges on improving the Android-powered Find My Device ecosystem and capitalizing on Apple’s proven platform.
Which is right for you?
Go for what works now
If you’re torn between the Tile Pro and the Pebblebee Tag Universal — and especially if you use an iPhone —then consider skipping both and opting for Apple’s AirTag instead. For most Android users, however, the Tile Pro is the clear winner right now. Its loud alarm, well-established crowdsourced network, and top-notch IP68 durability make it a dependable choice. While it would be nice to see compatibility with Google’s Find My Device network, the current state of that ecosystem suggests Tile’s not missing out on much.
Yes, the Tile Pro’s premium features are stuck behind subscription walls, but you can still use it effectively without paying extra. If you’re holding out for Google’s Find My to evolve into something more reliable, there’s no telling how long you’ll wait. Meanwhile, the Tile Pro is here today, performing well and offering the kind of no-fuss experience you need.
Your changes have been saved
The practical pick
Tile Pro (2024)
Tried-and-tested tracker
$28 $35 Save $7
For Android users seeking a reliable and readily available tracking solution, the Tile Pro is the way to go. While we wish it could tap into Google’s Find My Device network, the network’s current limitations make that a minor drawback.
The Pebblebee Tag Universal, on the other hand, shows promise. Its compact size and ability to stick almost anywhere can be handy around the house. It can help locate misplaced essentials and sounds off when you call on it, which is nothing to scoff at. But if your top priorities are trustworthiness, sturdy waterproofing, and frequent, accurate location updates, Pebblebee’s current reliance on an underdeveloped Google network holds it back. Someday, that infrastructure may catch up, but until then, the Tile Pro stands as the more practical choice.
Your changes have been saved
Lots of potential
Pebblebee Tag Universal
<
p class=”display-card-subtitle”>Needs Google to do better
$28 $35 Save $7
While the Pebblebee Tag holds promise for the future, it’s not quite ready to dethrone the reigning champion. Its dependence on Google’s still-under-development Find My Device network hinders its performance.
Khám phá thêm từ Phụ Kiện Đỉnh
Đăng ký để nhận các bài đăng mới nhất được gửi đến email của bạn.
